Posts Tagged ‘means test’

Means test income figures changing Nov. 1

Monday, October 17th, 2011

That wacky Department of Justice is at it again. Starting November 1, the means test household median income numbers will be changing. These changes will make it slightly easier for some debtors to file for Chapter 7 after November 1 (and slightly harder for others).

The median income for a single filer with no dependents is increasing from $45,760 to $46,161, meaning that singles making between $45,760 and $46,161 will no longer be subject to the long-form means test calculation. The median income for families of two and four will decrease slightly. What’s a little odd, is that the median income for a family of three has taken a dive from $74,082 to $71,784. Your guess why is as good as mine.

Want to know more about what these changes will mean for your situation? Give us a call.

Domestic partnership and bankruptcy–an update

Friday, June 17th, 2011

In an earlier post, we explained that in Minnesota, same-sex domestic partners cannot file a joint case in bankruptcy, even if they were married in another state. This is still true.

However, in states where same-sex marriage is legal, the pendulum may start to swing the other way. In the Central District of California, 20 of the 24 bankruptcy judges signed onto an opinion ruling that the Defense of Marriage Act is unconstitutional insofar as it prevents same-sex legally-married couples from filing joint bankruptcy petitions.

This is not likely to have an immediate effect outside the Central District of California (Los Angeles and the surrounding area) but if other courts follow suit, it may eventually mean that same-sex couples who were married in a state that recognizes same-sex marriage may file joint petitions in any state.

While this is good news in terms of equal protection, it may be both a blessing and a curse under bankruptcy law. There are advantages to filing jointly, such as the fact that you only have to pay one filing fee to the court. The downside? Under current bankruptcy law, same-sex partners are treated like roommates, so the filing partner does not have to include their non-filing spouse’s income on the means test. If partners were treated the same as married couples, then we would need to count the non-filing partner’s income on the means test, then subtract amounts that don’t go to support the household. It may seem nuanced, but it’s kind of a big deal.

Even though the law hasn’t changed here in Minnesota, Blake and I still stand by our principles. We offer clients in domestic partnerships the same discounted price that we would offer a married couple filing bankruptcy, even though we have to file two separate cases.

Domestic partnership and bankruptcy

Tuesday, May 31st, 2011

domestic partnership and bankruptcyWe often work with same-sex couples dealing with debt. A few tricky issues come up with clients in domestic partnerships that want to file bankruptcy, but for the most part, the bankruptcy law treats them exactly the same as any non-married couples. Here are some questions we get asked a lot:

1. Can we file bankruptcy together? Only married couples can file joint bankruptcy cases. An unmarried couple will need to file separate cases regardless of age, height, star sign, or gender.

2. What if we were married in another state? No dice there. The federal Defense of Marriage Act denies federal recognition of same-sex marriage. So even though same-sex marriage may confer certain benefits in the states where it’s legal, this doesn’t extend to the bankruptcy law.

3. Does my domestic partner count toward my household size on the means test? In determining household size for the purposes of the means test, you can count any person with whom you share a household–even a roommate counts as long as you share household expenses. If you have kids, both partners can count the kids in household size under the means test.

4. Do I have to count my domestic partner’s income toward my ability to pay creditors on the means test? In counting income, we only count a partner’s income if it is paid toward the household expenses of the debtor. This is usually more favorable than the way a married single-filer is treated under the bankruptcy code. If married, you have to add all your spouse’s income as household income, and then subtract any money that does not go into the household as a “marital adjustment” (such as the spouse’s monthly payments to debt in his/her own name). For unmarried couples, all we do is add the portion of the non-filing spouse’s income that is paid toward the expenses of the debtor or his/her dependents.

5. Will our case cost the same as it would if we filed together? Domestic partners the same discounted price that we would offer a married couple filing bankruptcy, even though we have to file two separate cases. The only difference is that because you’d be filing two separate cases, there will be two separate filing fees ($306 per person in a Chapter 7).

There are other issues to watch out for, especially if you and your partner own property jointly. Get in touch for a free consultation if we can help you figure some of these issues out.

What does it cost to file Chapter 7 bankruptcy?

Wednesday, May 11th, 2011

I guess it’s no surprise that our chapter 7 bankruptcy clients are often cash-strapped. So one of the first things a potential client wants to know during a consultation is how much bankruptcy costs. Obviously, every case is different, but here’s a rough version of what we tell clients about how much bankruptcy costs.

1. We charge a flat fee. If you’re considering Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you don’t want to worry about your lawyer running up the fee as he churns hours on your case. Flat fee billing gives our clients predictability–we quote you a fee before you sign up with us, and that’s what you’ll pay.

2. The amount of the fee depends. For a basic Chapter 7 for a single filer, we charge $1,700. For a joint filing, it’s $2,500 (there, I said it).

But not every case turns out to be basic, so it doesn’t mean that’s exactly what we’ll charge in your case. Your fee will be based on our best prediction of the complexity of your Chapter 7 case. One example: if a client is above median income, involving a much more detailed analysis under the means test, that case may cost more. There are other factors that may affect the complexity of your case, so here’s my advice on price-shopping–if a bankruptcy attorney can quote you a one-size-fits-all price before understanding your particular issues, run away. That lawyer probably doesn’t understand just how complex some cases can be.

3. There are fees in bankruptcy that don’t go to us. In a Chapter 7 case, there is a court filing fee of $306 and mandatory credit counseling fees (for our clients, credit counseling runs around $70 for a single filer or $90 for joint filers). You pay those fees to us and we forward them as needed.

4. Your Chapter 7 bankruptcy fee must be paid before we file your case. If we file your bankruptcy case and you haven’t paid our entire fee, the debt to us is discharged along with all your other debts. We’re out of luck. You might not want to hire the lawyer who doesn’t understand this concept and offers to let you pay after the bankruptcy is filed.

Last tip–you may not want to bargain-hunt on bankruptcy. The best lawyers will quote you a fair price, but the worst ones will probably discount their fees to try to take business from the good ones. You want a lawyer who’s experienced enough to understand a lot of the tricks and traps of bankruptcy. You also want someone who’ll be available to answer your questions, and won’t blow you off because they’re too busy with all their other cases. And you want someone who’s willing to use the bankruptcy law creatively to help you improve your situation. As it happens, we know a couple of guys who fit the bill pretty well.

The Means Test: What is a means test and is it going to stop me from filing Chapter 7?

Wednesday, March 23rd, 2011

The means test is one of the bankruptcy mysteries our clients ask about most often. The means test was created by the 2005 bankruptcy amendments, and was meant to make it harder for high-income folks to file bankruptcy.

To decide whether clients qualify to discharge their debts in Chapter 7, the courts are concerned with two major questions: 1) Does a consumer have enough assets to pay off their debt? and 2) Does a consumer have enough income to pay off their debt? The means test helps the court answer the second question.

To figure out whether a consumer has enough income to pay creditors, you might just compare what the consumer actually makes with what he actually spends, and see if there’s anything left over at the end of the month. But looking at each consumer’s individual budget would require the court to make some tricky judgments about whether his grocery bills are reasonable or whether he’s spending too much money on pay-per-view. So instead, the means test looks at some of the most common expenses and standardizes them so everyone gets the same deduction.

Here’s how this works in practice–your attorney will compile the last six months of all income your household has received, and compare it against the median household income of a family your size in your state (for example, as of this post, the median household size for a family of two in Minnesota was $61,690.) This information is available on some handy tables on the U.S. Trustee’s web site. If your household income is less than the median, congratulations–you’ve finished the form and you can file Chapter 7!

If your household income is more than the median, you may still be able to file Chapter 7, but there are a whole set of other calculations that your attorney will need to go through involving your monthly expenses to find out. These include some standard expenses that can be found on the U.S. Trustee’s web site, as well as some actual monthly expenses. Once you deduct these expenses from monthly income, the goal is generally to have a very low number for your leftover–or disposable–income.

But filling out the means test form requires a whole lot more than just looking up some numbers and plugging them into a chart. First of all, some of the deductions are backward-looking over the past six months. Some are forward-looking. And some are hypothetical (an expense is allowed if you should be spending on it). Also, many of the expenses have rules–you can’t take the expense unless certain criteria are met. These rules are based on the Bankruptcy Code and court cases interpreting the bankruptcy law. This is why you’ll need a good attorney who knows the ins and outs of bankruptcy, not just someone who will fill out your bankruptcy forms without much legal analysis.

These are just the basics. In future posts, we’ll try to go more in-depth so you can understand more about the means test and how you can qualify for Chapter 7 bankruptcy. Give us a call if you’re wondering if you’ll pass the means test.

It’s about to get slightly harder to file for Chapter 7

Wednesday, October 13th, 2010

The means test in bankruptcy is the gateway to filing a Chapter 7 case. In order to determine whether a debtor will qualify for a Chapter 7, attorneys perform a complex set of calculations using a set of standard dollar figures based on family size and location. These standard figures are published by the U.S. Trustee’s office and sometimes change as the cost of living changes.

The U.S. Trustee has issued a new set of numbers, scheduled to go into effect November 1, 2010, and the median income for Minnesota has decreased. This means that a filer’s household income, based on family size, must be lower than before to automatically qualify for Chapter 7. For example, the median income for a household of two is currently $62,162. Under the new numbers, the median for that household size will be $60,694.

What does all this mean? Well, remember the rush to file before the bankruptcy law changed in 2005? This time, we may see a mini-spike in bankruptcy filings leading up to October 31 as people try to file under the old means test figures. And it may mean that more clients will fall above the new median income figures, which could mean more Chapter 13 cases will be filed, or that Chapter 7 cases will be more complicated for the attorneys handling them (and therefore more expensive for clients).

Contact a bankruptcy attorney (like me) to discuss the impact of this change on your situation.